User Tools

Site Tools


blog:madhyama-adhikari-can-act-as-a-diksha-guru

Madhyama-adhikari Can Act as a Diksha Guru

(This post was originally published at Sampradaya Sun site.)

In the course of my regular reading of Srimad Bhagavatam, I've stumbled upon a nice quote from Srila Prabhupada in regard to the exchange going on between H.H. Bhakti Vikasa Swami and H.G. Sattvic Prabhu. Let me state that I've read the post with Sattvic Prabhu's questions and listened the whole lecture given by Bhakti Vikasa Maharaja, answering all the points raised by Sattvic Prabhu.

In his article entitled Conditioned Souls as Diksha Gurus? An Indefensible Position, Sattvic Prabhu concludes with the following:

A madhyam-adikary can act as guru but cannot act as a diksha guru, since the prospective disciple cannot advance under his insufficient guidance.

Only the liberated maha-bhagavata uttama-adikari can initiate disciples and perform the function of a diksha guru by dispensing divya jnana and removing the sinful reactions from the heart of the disciple.

However, the following quote from Srila Prabhupada's purport to Srimad Bhagavatam 2.3.21 says:

“As stated hereinbefore, there are three kinds of devotees of the Lord. The first-class devotee does not at all see anyone who is not in the service of the Lord, but the second-class devotee makes distinctions between devotees and nondevotees. The second-class devotees are therefore meant for preaching work, and as referred to in the above verse, they must loudly preach the glories of the Lord. The second-class devotee accepts disciples from the section of third-class devotees or nondevotees. Sometimes the first-class devotee also comes down to the category of the second-class devotee for preaching work.”

So, it's very clear that the second-class devotee (aka madhyama-adhikari) is “meant for preaching work”, but also “second-class devotee accepts disciples from the section of third-class devotees or nondevotees.”

As far as first-class (aka uttama-adhikari) devotee is concerned, Srila Prabhupada says that: “Sometimes the first-class devotee also comes down to the category of the second-class devote for preaching work”, which clearly shows that the conclusion, “Only the liberated maha-bhagavata uttama-adhikari can initiate disciples and perform the function of a diksha guru…” is simply not in accordance with the Bhaktivedanta purports.

your servant,
Gour-Gadadhara Dasa

Discussion

Sarah, 08.03.2023 14:10

https://www.nikeair-maxs.us.com/ https://www.balenciagaofficial.us.com/ https://www.redbottomslouboutin.us.org/ https://www.jordansneakerss.us/ https://www.jordan-retro6.us/ https://www.jordan1universityblue.us.com/ https://www.balenciagatriples.us.org/ https://www.pandoraonline.us/ https://www.ggdbs.us.com/ https://www.nikeair-jordan1.us.com/ https://www.airjordan11s.us.com/ https://www.jordan13s.us/ https://www.christian-louboutinheels.us.com/ https://www.nikeairjordan.us.com/ https://www.ggdbshoes.us.com/ https://www.redbottomshoesforwomen.us.com/ https://www.air-jordanssneakers.us/ https://www.jordan-retro1.us.com/ https://www.jordan14.us.com/ https://www.outletgoldengoose.us.com/ https://www.ferragamos.us.org/ https://www.monclerstores.us.com/ https://www.jordans1.us.com/ https://www.jordans-4.us/ https://www.jordan-shoesformen.us.com/ https://www.airmax270.us.org/ https://www.jordan10.us.com/ https://www.nikeoutletstoresonlineshopping.us.com/ https://www.pandorajewelryofficial-site.us/ https://www.airjordan6rings.us/ https://www.jordan12retro.us.com/ https://www.nikeoutletfactorys.us.com/ https://www.christianslouboutin.uk.com/ https://www.retrosjordans.us/ https://www.nmds.us.com/ https://www.air-jordansneakers.us/ https://www.pandorajewelryofficialsite.us.com/ https://www.airmax-95.us.com/ https://www.jordan11ssneakers.us/ https://www.nikeoutletshoes.us.com/ https://www.jordans-11.us/ https://www.nike-airmax2018.us.com/ https://www.newjordan11.us/ https://www.jordans1s.us.com/ https://www.air-jordan6.us.com/ https://www.newjordansshoes.us.com/ https://www.airjordansnew.us.com/ https://www.airmax270s.us.com/ https://www.pandoras.us.com/ https://www.goldensgoose.us.com/ https://www.jordanretros.us.com/ https://www.airjordanretro11.us.com/ https://www.soccercleats.us.com/ https://www.outletnikestore.us.com/ https://www.eccos.us.com/ https://www.christianslouboutinshoes.us.com/ https://www.yeezyonline.us.com/ https://www.airforceoneshoes.us.com/ https://www.air-jordan1s.us.com/ https://www.nikeofficialwebsite.us.com/ https://www.huarachesnike.us.com/ https://www.nikesales.us.com/ https://www.retrosairjordan.us/ https://www.air-max90.us.com/ https://www.jordans5.us/ https://www.jordans11.us.com/ http://www.pandorarings.us.com/ https://www.jordan11low.us.com/ https://www.shoeslouboutin.us.com/ https://www.pandoracanadajewelry.ca/ https://www.goldengooseshoess.us.com/ https://www.canadapandoracharms.ca/ https://www.retro-jordans.us/ https://www.jordan13.us.org/ https://www.jordanshoesretro.us.com/ https://www.sneakersgoldengoose.us.com/ https://www.jordan-12.us.com/ https://www.pandora-braceletcharms.us/ https://www.monclercom.us.com/ https://www.newnikeshoes.us.com/ https://www.adidasyeezysneakers.us.com/ https://www.air-jordan6.us/ https://www.valentinosshoes.us.org/ https://www.new-jordans.us.com/ https://www.goldengoosesales.us.com/ https://www.nikesnkrs.us.com/ https://www.birkin-bag.us.com/ https://www.adidasnmdr1.us.org/ https://www.pandorascharms.us.com/ https://www.nikesfactory.us.com/ https://www.kyrieirving-shoes.us.org/ https://www.nike--shoes.us.com/ https://www.nike-jordans.us.com/ https://www.nikeairmax98.us/ https://www.goldengooseoutletfactory.us.com/ https://www.jordans-sneakers.us.com/ https://www.pandorajewellery.us.com/ https://www.mensnikeshoes.us.com/ https://www.christianlouboutinshoesinc.us.com/ https://www.jordanshoess.us.com/ https://www.coatsmoncler.us.com/ https://www.jordan1.us.com/ https://www.adidasyeezysshoes.us.com/ https://www.vanscom.us.com/ https://www.jordan12retros.us/ https://www.jordansretro12.us/ https://www.nikeshoesforwomens.us.com/ https://www.airjordan3s.us/ https://www.jordan11red.us.com/ https://www.airjordan4s.us/ https://www.air-jordan4.us.com/ https://www.fjallraven-kanken.us.com/ https://www.airjordan1s.us.org/ https://www.redbottomshoeslouboutin.us.com/ https://www.nikesoutletstoreonlineshopping.us.com/ https://www.louboutinshoesheels.us.com/ https://www.goldengoosessneakers.us.com/ https://www.yeezys-shoes.us.org/ https://www.jordan1lows.us.com/ https://www.airjordanshoess.us.com/ https://www.jordan-4.us.com/ https://www.asics-running-shoes.us.com/ https://www.jordanscheapshoes.us/ https://www.air-jordan12.us/ https://www.fitflop-shoes.us.org/ https://www.jordanretro-11.us.com/ https://www.airjordan5.us/ https://www.jordansshoesforsale.us.com/ https://www.jordan-8.us/ https://www.jordan5.us.com/ https://www.monclerjacketsstore.us.com/ https://www.monclervest.us.com/ https://www.yeezys-shoes.us.com/ https://www.jordan11sshoes.us/ https://www.jordanretro11mens.us/ https://www.yeezy.us.org/ https://www.nikefactoryoutlets.us.org/ https://www.yeezys.com.co/ https://www.jordan9.us.com/ https://www.goldengoosesneakerss.us.com/ https://www.goldengoosemidstar.us.com/ https://www.jordansretro3.us/ https://www.ggdbsneakers.us.com/ https://www.nikeshoes-cheap.us.com/ https://www.nikeshoesoutletfactory.us.com/ https://www.air-jordans11.us.com/ https://www.jordans4retro.us/ https://www.jacketsmoncleroutlet.us.com/ https://www.pandorasjewelry.us.com/ https://www.jamesharden-shoes.us.org/ https://www.pandoraringssite.us/ https://www.nikeairmax-shoes.us.com/ https://www.lebron-shoes.us.com/ https://www.airjordansneakers.us.com/

Rodolfo, 19.03.2023 09:34

https://www.fitflop-shoes.us.org/ https://www.nikesfactory.us.com/ https://www.nikeair-maxs.us.com/ https://www.soccercleats.us.com/ https://www.jordan11low.us.com/ https://www.newnikeshoes.us.com/ https://www.nikeair-jordan1.us.com/ https://www.jordan5.us.com/ https://www.retrosairjordan.us/ https://www.monclercom.us.com/ https://www.ggdbsneakers.us.com/ https://www.airjordan11s.us.com/ https://www.airmax270.us.org/ https://www.canadapandoracharms.ca/ https://www.jordansshoesforsale.us.com/ https://www.jordansretro12.us/ https://www.yeezy.us.org/ https://www.retrosjordans.us/ https://www.adidasyeezysneakers.us.com/ https://www.goldengooseshoess.us.com/ https://www.goldengoosessneakers.us.com/ https://www.airforceoneshoes.us.com/ https://www.airmax-95.us.com/ https://www.jordan10.us.com/ https://www.goldengoosesales.us.com/ https://www.nike--shoes.us.com/ https://www.jordan11sshoes.us/ https://www.shoeslouboutin.us.com/ https://www.jordanretro11mens.us/ https://www.airjordanretro11.us.com/ https://www.jamesharden-shoes.us.org/ https://www.jordansretro3.us/ https://www.air-max90.us.com/ https://www.nmds.us.com/ https://www.jordan13.us.org/ https://www.pandorajewelryofficialsite.us.com/ https://www.retro-jordans.us/ https://www.nikeoutletfactorys.us.com/ https://www.pandoras.us.com/ https://www.goldengoosemidstar.us.com/ https://www.yeezys.com.co/ https://www.jordans5.us/ https://www.christianslouboutin.uk.com/ https://www.coatsmoncler.us.com/ https://www.ggdbshoes.us.com/ https://www.pandoracanadajewelry.ca/ https://www.nikeshoes-cheap.us.com/ https://www.monclerstores.us.com/ https://www.airjordansneakers.us.com/ https://www.adidasnmdr1.us.org/ https://www.sneakersgoldengoose.us.com/ https://www.jordanshoess.us.com/ https://www.pandoraringssite.us/ https://www.pandorajewellery.us.com/ https://www.airjordanshoess.us.com/ https://www.nikesnkrs.us.com/ https://www.jordan1.us.com/ https://www.fjallraven-kanken.us.com/ https://www.jordan-retro1.us.com/ https://www.nikeoutletshoes.us.com/ https://www.huarachesnike.us.com/ https://www.jordan-shoesformen.us.com/ https://www.redbottomshoesforwomen.us.com/ https://www.asics-running-shoes.us.com/ https://www.jordan-8.us/ https://www.newjordan11.us/ https://www.jordanscheapshoes.us/ https://www.redbottomshoeslouboutin.us.com/ https://www.valentinosshoes.us.org/ https://www.jordans-11.us/ https://www.jordansneakerss.us/ https://www.christian-louboutinheels.us.com/ https://www.nike-jordans.us.com/ https://www.airjordan5.us/ https://www.pandoraonline.us/ https://www.nikeairmax98.us/ https://www.jordan-4.us.com/ https://www.pandorascharms.us.com/ http://www.pandorarings.us.com/ https://www.jordanretros.us.com/ https://www.christianlouboutinshoesinc.us.com/ https://www.nikeshoesforwomens.us.com/ https://www.nikeofficialwebsite.us.com/ https://www.jordan1lows.us.com/ https://www.jordan13s.us/ https://www.goldensgoose.us.com/ https://www.air-jordanssneakers.us/ https://www.jordanshoesretro.us.com/ https://www.nikeairjordan.us.com/ https://www.airjordan3s.us/ https://www.air-jordansneakers.us/ https://www.ggdbs.us.com/ https://www.air-jordan4.us.com/ https://www.jordans1s.us.com/ https://www.airmax270s.us.com/ https://www.jordan-12.us.com/ https://www.jordanretro-11.us.com/ https://www.yeezys-shoes.us.com/ https://www.redbottomslouboutin.us.org/ https://www.eccos.us.com/ https://www.goldengooseoutletfactory.us.com/ https://www.lebron-shoes.us.com/ https://www.outletgoldengoose.us.com/ https://www.airjordan6rings.us/ https://www.pandorajewelryofficial-site.us/ https://www.nikesoutletstoreonlineshopping.us.com/ https://www.air-jordans11.us.com/ https://www.air-jordan1s.us.com/ https://www.nikeshoesoutletfactory.us.com/ https://www.newjordansshoes.us.com/ https://www.balenciagaofficial.us.com/ https://www.jordan1universityblue.us.com/ https://www.nikeoutletstoresonlineshopping.us.com/ https://www.jordan11ssneakers.us/ https://www.airjordansnew.us.com/ https://www.new-jordans.us.com/ https://www.jordan9.us.com/ https://www.jordans-4.us/ https://www.air-jordan12.us/ https://www.outletnikestore.us.com/ https://www.pandorasjewelry.us.com/ https://www.louboutinshoesheels.us.com/ https://www.jordan11red.us.com/ https://www.monclervest.us.com/ https://www.jordan12retros.us/ https://www.nikefactoryoutlets.us.org/ https://www.kyrieirving-shoes.us.org/ https://www.balenciagatriples.us.org/ https://www.adidasyeezysshoes.us.com/ https://www.nikesales.us.com/ https://www.ferragamos.us.org/ https://www.airjordan1s.us.org/ https://www.yeezys-shoes.us.org/ https://www.pandora-braceletcharms.us/ https://www.nikeairmax-shoes.us.com/ https://www.air-jordan6.us/ https://www.jordans11.us.com/ https://www.birkin-bag.us.com/ https://www.jordans4retro.us/ https://www.nike-airmax2018.us.com/ https://www.yeezyonline.us.com/ https://www.airjordan4s.us/ https://www.christianslouboutinshoes.us.com/ https://www.jordan14.us.com/ https://www.jacketsmoncleroutlet.us.com/ https://www.goldengoosesneakerss.us.com/ https://www.jordan-retro6.us/ https://www.jordan12retro.us.com/ https://www.mensnikeshoes.us.com/ https://www.jordans-sneakers.us.com/ https://www.air-jordan6.us.com/ https://www.monclerjacketsstore.us.com/ https://www.vanscom.us.com/ https://www.jordans1.us.com/

bestrvguide, 31.05.2023 06:04

From 4K UHD to OLED, we have a Smart TV to suit every taste and budget. Browse our selection today and find the perfect TV for your home. https://bestrvguide.com/

yeezy, 22.07.2023 02:34

https://www.yeezyadidas.de/ Yeezy https://www.yeezys.co/ Yeezys https://www.jordan-1.org/ Jordan 1 https://www.air-jordan1.com/ Air Jordan 1 https://www.nikejordan1.com/ Nike Jordan 1 https://www.jordan-1s.com/ Jordan 1S https://www.jordan1.uk.com/ Jordan 1 https://www.jordans-shoes.com/ Jordan Shoes https://www.jordan-shoes.us.com/ Jordan Shoes https://www.nikeuk.uk.com/ Nike UK https://www.yeezy-450.com/ Yeezy 450 https://www.jordanretro4.com/ Jordan Retro 4 https://www.nikeoutletstoreonlineshopping.us/ Nike Outlet Store Online Shopping https://www.yeezy.uk.com/ YEEZY https://www.adidasyeezyofficialwebsite.com/ Adidas Yeezy Official Website https://www.yeezy350.uk.com/ Yeezy 350 https://www.air-jordan4.com/ Air Jordan 4 https://www.yeezyfoam-runner.com/ Yeezy Foam Runner https://www.yeezyslides.us.com/ Yeezy Slides https://www.ray-ban-glasses.us.com/ Ray Ban Glasses https://www.adidasuk.uk.com/ Adidas UK https://www.nflshopofficialonlinestore.com/ NFL Shop Official Online Store https://www.yeezys-slides.us.com/ Yeezy Slides https://www.yeezyadidass.us.com/ Adidas Yeezy https://www.350yeezy.us.com/ Yeezy 350 https://www.yeezyy.us.com/ Yeezy https://www.yeezy350s.us.com/ Yeezy 350 https://www.shoesyeezys.us.com/ Yeezy Shoes https://www.yeezys.uk.com/ Yeezys https://www.off-white.us.org// Off White https://raybansales.us/ Ray Ban https://www.adidasyeezy.uk.com/ Adidas Yeezy https://www.yzyshoes.us.com/ Yeezy Shoes https://www.yeezy-shoes.us.com/ Yeezy Shoes https://www.yeezy-700.us.com/ Yeezy 700 https://www.yeezyadidas.de/ Adidas Yeezy https://www.yeezys.co/ Yeezy https://www.jordan-1.org/ Nike Jordan 1 https://www.air-jordan1.com/ Jordan 1 https://www.nikejordan1.com/ Jordan 1 https://www.jordan-1s.com/ Jordan 1 https://www.jordan1.uk.com/ Jordan UK https://www.jordans-shoes.com/ Jordans Shoes https://www.jordan-shoes.us.com/ Jordan https://www.nikeuk.uk.com/ Nike https://www.yeezy-450.com/ Yeezy https://www.jordanretro4.com/ Jordan 4 https://www.nikeoutletstoreonlineshopping.us/ Nike Outlet https://www.yeezy.uk.com/ YEEZY UK https://www.adidasyeezyofficialwebsite.com/ Adidas Yeezy https://www.yeezy350.uk.com/ Yeezy uk https://www.air-jordan4.com/ Jordan 4 https://www.yeezy-supply.com/ Yeezys Supply https://www.yeezyfoam-runner.com/ Yeezy https://www.yeezyslides.us.com/ YEEZY https://www.ray-ban-glasses.us.com/ Ray Bans Sunglasses https://www.adidasuk.uk.com/ Adidas https://www.nflshopofficialonlinestore.com/ NFL Shop https://www.yeezys-slides.us.com/ Yeezys https://www.yeezyadidass.us.com/ Adidas Yeezys https://www.350yeezy.us.com/ Yeezy 350 V2 https://www.yeezyy.us.com/ Yeezys https://www.yeezy350s.us.com/ Yeezy Boost 350 https://www.shoesyeezys.us.com/ Yeezys Shoes https://www.yeezys.uk.com/ Yeezy https://raybansales.us/ Ray Bans https://www.adidasyeezy.uk.com/ Yeezy https://www.yzyshoes.us.com/ Yeezys https://www.yeezy-slides.org/ Adidas Yeezy Slides https://www.yeezy-shoes.us.com/ Yeezy https://www.yeezy-700.us.com/ Yeezy https://cheapyeezysonline.com/ Cheap Yeezys https://yeezysupplystore.com/ Yeezy Supply https://www.yeezyshoesonline.com/ Yeezy Shoes https://www.yeezys-supply.us.com/ Yeezy Supply https://www.yeezys-supply.us.com/ Yeezys https://www.yeezy-s.com/ Yeezy Shoes https://www.yeezy-s.us/ Yeezy https://yeezysale.us/ Yeezy https://www.pandorajewelries.us.com/ Pandora Jewelry Tags:yeezy shoes, Yeezy, Adidas Yeezy

Enter your comment. Wiki syntax is allowed:
Q G Q Y H
 
blog/madhyama-adhikari-can-act-as-a-diksha-guru.txt · Last modified: 29.12.2020 17:56 by gour